1865 Indian Head Penny Value and Grading: What You Need to Know

The coin was created by James B. Longacre, the Chief Engraver of the U. S. Mint, who labored on several famous coins. The Indian Head cents of 1865 were struck in the year 1865. The Indian Head penny is what most people associate him with. With other 1865 Indian head penny varieties, he also produced a 2-cent piece in 1864, the first currency in the United States to include the legend IN GOD WE TRUST

Instead of an image of Miss Liberty wearing a typical Native American headdress, the "Indian" on the cent is a photograph of Miss Liberty wearing a traditional Native American headdress. This is what the "Indian" on the penny seems to be.

The Value of the 1865 Indian Penny


Because this coin was made after the Civil War, it is called an "Indian Head Penny." It isn't as interesting to investors as some of the coins made before and during the war were more unique. It was still the first coins made with a 95 percent copper alloy that people used to make them. 

They'd keep using this metal for years, but these coins were the first made with it. With the great 1865 Indian head penny worth, also there were a lot of coins like this made during the time this one was made. 

They came from all over the United States. It's only a small part of the original lot left now, and collectors always want to get their hands on it. 

1865 Indian Head Penny Value


About 1865 Indian Head Penny Fancy 5


The 1865 Indian Cent is available in two different varieties: the Fancy 5 (which nearly seems to be italicized) and the Plain 5. The 1865 Indian head penny fancy 5 is the year's type coin; however, it is still fairly difficult to come by. 

This is a highly accessible coin that is somewhat more uncommon than the norm in circulating grades and difficult to get by in Mint State, particularly diamonds.

Surviving Indian Penny from 1865

It is only now that the elevated areas of this 1865 coin are beginning to show signs of coloration. This gives it a really attractive appearance. 

Even though the color has been obscured by the tone, the vibrant shine can still be seen flashing through. Combining these characteristics with the fact that the coin has no nicks from contact, it immediately distinguishes itself from the other surviving coins.

There were a lot of bids when the coins were sold at David Lawrence's rare coin auctions. This shows how popular the coins are for both coin collectors and dealers. 

This Indian head penny from 1865 was worth $408. A good coin to own, and many people will buy it if it's time to sell. People will buy it if it's time to sell. 

There are many people today who like to collect old coins, even if they're a little dirty. With this in mind, judge your coins. Many of them are worth a lot of money because they are in a collection and have a history.

How Do You Grade The 1865 Indian Head Penny?


When grading this Indian Head coin, or any other currency, the coin's appearance is the most important factor. 

Because these coins were produced so long ago, it is not uncommon to come across examples that are much worn and exhibit signs of their age. Knowing the grade of your coin will allow you to determine how much it is worth in the future. 


Here are a few resources you may use to determine how much your coins are worth on the open market.

1. Uncirculated

Good because there are no marks on the surface. Despite its age, this penny is worth more than most 1865 Indian head pennyworth. 

So the design is still not changed, the tone could look like dark reds and browns because of that. Having a magnifying glass, stare at her cheek and feather edges to see if they've been worn. Once coins are chosen to wear, they can glow brightly or smooth, and sometimes there is a dull spot in the area.

2. Extremely Fine

Sharp details can still be seen on Indian coins in very good condition. Flattening is only on a small part of some of the coins, even though they've been worn down a little bit. 

Coins have a "Liberty" found inside the headband. Make sure you put on this first. Each letter must be there to get an "extremely good" grade from the teacher.

3. Fine

It doesn't matter that some of the metal on this 1865 penny has worn off. It still looks very sharp and crisp and has a good value. Make sure the "Liberty" in the headband can be read. 

Some letters might be a little blurred. Her cheek is still mostly round and the hair detail on her neck and near her eye is still there. If you want to get a "fine" grade for your design, you need to separate each part of it.

4. Good

Because this 1865 Indian penny has been through a lot, it is in "good" shape. When it comes to your health, it doesn't matter what condition you are in. 

The main parts of the design are still visible even when the ground is very low. When you look at the headdress, it doesn't look like much of it is visible. 

But the feathers have a little curve to them. It is possible to see all of the letterings as you move around the rim of the glass.

Other Years From This Coin Series:

1859 1860 1861
1862 1863 1864
1865 1866 1867
1868 1869 1870
1871 1872 1873
1874 1875 1876
1877 1878 1879
1880 1881 1882
1883 1884 1885
1886 1887 1888
1889 1890 1891
1892 1893 1894
1895 1896 1897
1898 1899 1900
1901 1902 1903
1904 1905 1906
1907 1908 1909


Pricing for 1865 Indian Heads

It all comes down to how well it's been taken care of. Most of the time, when people buy these coins, the most well-preserved ones sell for the most money. If a coin has changed hands many times, it isn't so valuable. You can see how much these coins cost in the chart below. As long as it's in good condition, the 1865 Indian Head penny can be worth $15. About $30 if it's in good shape. There is a value of about $45 if the item is in good condition. Buying coins that haven't been used will set you back about $90. Coins with an MS60 grade are much more expensive. An MS 63 coin that has not been used can be worth about $150. if the 1865 Indian Head proof penny has a grade of PR 63, it's worth about $375.

Previous Post Next Post

Contact Form